FIRST GAY FANTASY Glory Holes 5 min

5 minCzech Gay Fantasy - 7M Views -

First Gay Experience 5 min

5 minEast Boys - 11.1M Views -

Army Jock Helps Bunkmate Accept Himself & Gives His First Gay Experience 20 min

20 minDisruptiveFilms - 2.5M Views -

My first fisting Part 2 22 sec

22 secDfwbiaustin -

Travis Splits Oliver's Tight Virgin Ass For The First Time Ever In A Sexy FlipFuck! 13 min

13 mingayhoopla - 1.7M Views -

Young Alex sucking a cock for the first time! 11 min

11 minPornberries - 2.4M Views -

Young boyfriends first time real gay, anal sex! 15 min

15 minPornberries - 38.2M Views -

Virgin ass First Time 53 sec

53 secSuperputitotragon -

Homemade gay virgin losing his cherry 54 sec

54 secJameswinkler -

Hot Muscle Jocks Have Their First Gay Threesome - StagCollective 14 min

14 minStagCollective - 257.2k Views -

ActiveDuty - Johnny B Helps Amateur Through His First Gay Fuck 10 min

10 minActiveDuty Official - 478.1k Views -

Deflowering Koldo Goran By Magic Javi 10 min

10 minBLESSEXXX GAY - 1.5M Views -

Greyson's first fuck 5 min

5 minGuys In Sweat Pants - 543.8k Views -

Young Straight Male Gets His Anal Cherry Popped Bareback Style 11 min

11 minNextDoorStudios Official - 1.2M Views -

Cum Meat - Very Gay Twinks First Time Anal 19 min

19 minCum Meat - 155.7k Views -

NextDoorStudios - Favorites First Time Poundings 54 min

54 minNextDoorStudios Official - 612.3k Views -

Male Escort Takes It Slow For Client's First Gay Experience. - DisruptiveFilms 25 min

25 minDisruptiveFilms - 3.2M Views -

NextDoorStudios Straight Virgin Nerd Dicks Step Bro 4 First Time 11 min

11 minNextDoorStudios Official - 3.6M Views -

ActiveDuty - Eager Military Muscle Jocks' First Time Anal 10 min

10 minActiveDuty Official - 777.7k Views -

NextDoorTwink - Camera Shy Twink Makes His First Sex Scene 13 min

13 minNextDoorStudios Official - 2.2M Views -

Straight Ben Gets Fucked For the First Time - RealityDudes 6 min

6 minReality Dudes - 1.4M Views -

BLUMITŠLIPAS DUMATŠLIPIT ['enhanced time'] 48 min

48 minZiblizet - 424.7k Views -

Twink Starts Liking Men After Receiving Heart Transplant From Gay Man - DisruptiveFilms 18 min

18 minDisruptiveFilms - 1.6M Views -

Porn Casting - Straight Latino and his first time having gay anal sex 6 min

6 minOmar Castell C - 65.6k Views -

First Gay Cum Set with Andy G(Thriller) 34 sec

34 secfunfor10k - 2.3k Views -

Awkward Straight Guys First Gay Encounter 6 min

6 minHoehazel -